Choosing a school can be hard enough when both parents agree. When you’re separated and have different ideas about what’s best for your child, it can become a much bigger issue.

One parent might want a private school while the other thinks the local public school is a better fit. Maybe your child is due to start high school, or one parent wants to change schools after moving house.

Whatever the disagreement, it’s easy for conversations about education to turn into arguments about money, parenting or who gets to make the final decision.

What happens when you can’t agree? Australian family law provides ways to resolve these disputes, but the right approach depends on your circumstances and any existing parenting arrangements.

Who Gets to Decide Which School a Child Attends?

There’s no automatic rule that gives one parent the final say on schooling simply because the child lives with them more often.

Under Australian family law, decisions about education can fall within parental responsibility for major long-term issues. Whether parents need to make these decisions jointly depends on the circumstances and any parenting orders in place.

If you share responsibility for major long-term decisions, you’re generally expected to consult each other and make a genuine effort to reach an agreement. You shouldn’t assume you can enrol your child in a new school or change their current arrangements without considering the other parent’s rights and any relevant court orders.

The starting point is always your child’s best interests. That means looking at their education and wellbeing, rather than focusing only on what either parent wants.

If you’re unsure who can make the decision, get legal advice before taking action.

What If You Disagree About Private School vs Public School?

This is a common sticking point for separated parents. One parent might believe private school will give their child better opportunities while the other may feel a public school is just as good, is closer to home or makes more financial sense.

Neither option is better in the eyes of the law, what matters is how the proposed school fits your child’s needs and circumstances.

Some of the things you should consider:

Does the school offer the right learning environment, support and opportunities?

Would changing schools mean leaving close friends or disrupting an arrangement that’s working well?

Can both parents manage school drop-offs, pick-ups and activities around their existing commitments?

What does your child want? Depending on their age and maturity, their preferences may be relevant.

Can the family afford fees, uniforms, books, transport and other expenses?

A school might look ideal on paper but be difficult to manage in practice. Equally, the cheapest option isn’t necessarily the best fit.

Try to separate your concerns about the school from any frustration you have with your former partner. It’s not always easy, but keeping the discussion focused on your child gives you a better chance of finding the best solution.

What Can You Do If You Can’t Reach an Agreement?

If you’ve discussed the options repeatedly and aren’t getting anywhere, you don’t have to keep having the same argument.

Start by working out what each of you is actually concerned about. One parent might be focused on academic results, while the other is worried about school fees or the impact of changing schools. Once those concerns are clear, it may be easier to find an option that addresses both.

You could visit the schools together, speak with teachers or compare the practical arrangements before making a decision.

If you can, keep the conversation specific. Instead of arguing about which parent is right, talk about what each school offers and how it would affect your child day to day.

If direct conversations aren’t working, family dispute resolution may help you reach an agreement. This can help you and your former partner discuss the disagreement and consider possible solutions. They won’t decide which school your child should attend, but they can help keep the conversation constructive.

In many parenting matters, parents are generally expected to make a genuine effort to resolve disputes through family dispute resolution before applying to court, unless an exemption applies.

If you reach an agreement, you may be able to record it in a parenting plan or apply for consent orders if that’s appropriate for your situation.

Get Advice From a Family Lawyer

Sometimes, you need a clearer understanding of where you stand legally.

A family lawyer can explain your rights and responsibilities and help you work out the next steps. They can also advise you on how to approach the disagreement and whether further action may be necessary.

A child custody solicitor can help if the school dispute is part of a wider disagreement about parenting arrangements, especially if a proposed change could affect where your child lives or the time they spend with each parent.

Can the Court Decide Which School a Child Attends?

If you can’t resolve a significant disagreement about your child’s education, you may be able to ask the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia to determine the issue.

The court considers the child’s best interests and the circumstances of the particular case. It doesn’t side with the parent who wants private school, the parent who pays more of the child’s expenses or the parent the child lives with most of the time.

Court proceedings can be expensive and time-consuming, and they can put additional pressure on an already difficult family situation.

Who Pays the School Fees?

Even if you agree on a school, you might not agree on who should pay for it. Private school fees can be a real source of tension. One parent may be comfortable with the expense, while the other believes it’s unaffordable or unnecessary.

You shouldn’t assume that school fees will automatically be split equally. Also, one parent shouldn’t assume the other will contribute to a private school simply because they’ve enrolled the child there.

A child maintenance lawyer can help explain your financial obligations, how school expenses may be treated and what options are available if you can’t agree.

Keep Your Child Out of the Conflict

School disagreements can bring up strong feelings. You might genuinely believe your preferred school is the best option, and it can be frustrating when your former partner sees things differently.

Your child shouldn’t feel that they have to choose sides. Don’t ask them to decide between parents or make them feel responsible for the outcome. Their views may be relevant, depending on their age and maturity, but it’s up to the adults to work through the disagreement.

Try to keep conversations about school focused on your child’s needs, not what happened during the relationship or who has been the more reasonable parent.

You may not agree on everything, but you can still work towards a decision that gives your child the best chance to settle in and do well.

How BRLG (Bedrock Legal Group) Can Help

If you and your former partner can’t agree about your child’s school, BRLG can help you understand your legal position and work through your options.

Contact us today to discuss your circumstances and get advice on resolving your parenting dispute. Book your FREE consultation online now or call 03 9005 8284.