Working out what happens to the family home can be one of the hardest parts of separating. One person might want to sell, split the proceeds and move on, while the other wants to stay. That can be especially important when children are living in the home, or when one person simply isn’t ready to leave.

But what happens when you both want different things?

In Victoria, the family home is usually considered as part of the wider property settlement. So, it’s not simply a matter of looking at the house and deciding who gets what. Other assets and debts, including superannuation and other financial resources, may also need to be taken into account when working out how the overall property pool should be divided.

Can One Person Force the Sale of the Family Home?

If both parties own the property and there is no agreement or court order dealing with the home, one person generally can’t just decide that the house must be sold and expect the other person to leave.

Similarly, the person who wants to remain in the home doesn’t necessarily have an automatic right to stay there indefinitely.

The outcome depends on the circumstances of the separation and, if the matter cannot be resolved by agreement, the orders that may ultimately be made about the property.

This is one reason it is important to get advice before signing a contract to sell, refusing to sell or making other major decisions about the property.

What If One Person Wants to Keep the House?

Selling isn’t the only option. Depending on the circumstances, one person may be able to retain the family home as part of the property settlement. This could involve refinancing the mortgage and paying the other person their agreed or determined share of the property, along with appropriate adjustments for the other assets and liabilities.

For example, the value of the home, the outstanding mortgage, superannuation, savings and other assets may all form part of the broader financial picture. It’s important not to assume that owning 50% of the house automatically means receiving exactly 50% of the sale proceeds.

What About the Children?

If children live in the family home, this can make the situation more complicated.

The practical impact of selling the property may need to be considered alongside parenting arrangements, schooling, stability and where the kids will live. However, the fact that children live in the home does not automatically mean that the property cannot be sold.

The financial and parenting aspects of separation are related but are dealt with under different considerations. Getting advice early can help you understand how the two issues may interact in your particular circumstances.

Can You Agree Without Going to Court?

Yes, in fact, reaching an agreement can avoid the time, cost and uncertainty associated with court proceedings.

You might agree to sell the house and divide the proceeds, for one person to buy out the other, or to delay the sale until an agreed date or event. Whatever arrangement you reach, it is important to document it rather than relying on a verbal agreement.

If you reach agreement about your property and finances, you may be able to formalise it through consent orders or a financial agreement. Consent orders can make an agreement legally binding, and the Court must be satisfied that the proposed financial orders are just and equitable.

What If You Still Can’t Agree?

If attempts to negotiate or resolve the dispute have not worked, either party may be able to apply to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia for financial or property orders.

The Court can make orders dealing with the property pool, including orders concerning the family home. In some circumstances, orders can require a property to be transferred or sold.

It is also worth knowing that family law property legislation changed on 10 June 2025. The changes affect how property settlements are determined and include consideration of the economic effect of family violence where relevant.

Get Advice Before Making Decisions About the Home

If you and your former partner disagree about selling the family home, don’t assume that the person who wants to sell automatically gets their way or that the person who wants to stay can simply refuse.

Speaking with experienced Melbourne family lawyers can help you understand your position and the options available to you. The team at BRLG (Bedrock Legal Group) can provide advice about property settlements and family law proceedings for separating couples in Victoria.

Reach out to us today online or by calling 03 9005 8284 – Your first consultation is free.